marx_mentat [he/him, comrade/them]

  • 7 Posts
  • 815 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: February 23rd, 2023

help-circle









  • If your whole deck is printed someone might be a dick about it but otherwise fuck them if they have a problem with a bunch of fake cards. Most good decks (that other people would enjoy playing against) only have about a dozen of the expensive cards so it's really not that many proxy cards anyway. Playing against a deck that's filled with a bunch of $100+ cards sucks ass and will not make you many new friends.

    I usually just tell people I have the real card in another deck (I don't). It's really common for people to proxy expensive cards that they like to play in all their decks.

    For example, there's a guy at my lgs who plays there multiple days a week and he has a maze of ith in every single one of his decks. He has a literal briefcase full of decks so he would need at least 20 copies of that one card. You can find versions of it for around $5, which isn't that high as far magic cards go, but it's way too much for anyone to own multiple legit copies of. So anyway I've only ever seen him play proxy versions of that card and no one cares in the slightest. Everyone just kind of assumes one of his decks has the real one.



  • Yeah Nadu definitely stole the spotlight. That is honestly the first Necrodominance deck I've looked at so far. I've really only been paying attention to the casual side of mtg for the past year so I don't really know anything about the current competitive meta. That's a bummer that they missed the mark again. It's not really a great casual or commander card so I don't really see it ever.


  • Dang this is a great history lesson, thank you! I didn't make the connection to black vise getting banned and the necropotence popularity surge.

    It's funny, they are still trying to fix necropotence. Their latest attempt is Necrodominance, just released a few months ago (here are both prints, because I couldn't decide which version to post):

    Show
    Show

    It has the same cost and all of the restrictions of necropotence, plus a reduction in hand size, and the exiling of discarded cards penalty has been expanded to include any card or non-card (tokens) going to the graveyard from anywhere, not just from your hand.

    I don't think it's seeing a lot of tournament plays atm but I'm not paying that close attention to the tournament scene right now.


  • If you built your deck to win with a certain combination of cards you can just sacrifice life until you have them all in your hand and then win, all in one turn.

    It's kind of a lazy deck archetype that typically doesn't require you to pay attention to what your opponents are doing or interact with them in anyway. You just sort of play solitaire until you have your combo. Victories with this strategy feel cheap and hollow, and losing to it feels worse. The general strategy of sacrificing life for card draw is still valid though, but wotc usually designs mechanics like this to make sure the risk vs reward feels fair (a hallmark of black cards). However, this particular card was too easy to exploit and is no longer legal in most formats.

    There are some cards that cause you to gain 1 life whenever you draw a card, which would negate the cost of this ability and let you draw your entire deck, which would also be bad for you if you ever had to draw another card for some reason (such as from your draw step) and would cause you to lose the game from the "not being able to draw a card from your deck" rule. unless you had a way to put cards back into your deck so you could keep drawing from the top of it, but at that point what are you even doing lol

    That's all the lore I have to dump out of my brain about this particular topic. I hope someone can find something in it that is useful or insightful in some way.

    I just realized this was the dunk tank. Oh no my time oooaaaaaaauhhh