starkillerfish (she)

  • 7 Posts
  • 139 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: September 3rd, 2023

help-circle















  • Imperialism is the highest stage of capitalism, defined by the dominance of finance capital (over industrial capital) and its export from the imperial core to the periphery.

    Neo-colonialism is a specific case of a relationship between an imperial core country and a periphery country, where the periphery country is nominally independent, and the imperial core country uses indirect means of intimidation (instead of direct colonial rule). I would also note that the terms neo-colonialism and colonialism center the colony/periphery, while imperialism centers the imperialist state. So it is still the same phenomenon, the terms just focus on different parts of the relationship.



  • I don't think it is genocidal, but it is extremely chauvinistic. The main goal outlined in the text is the dismantling of the Ukrainian nation state, replacing it with people's republics under the supervision of Russia. My question relating to this would be, does denying the right to a nation state (without destroying the people) count as genocide? This article sort of draws a parallel with Germany post WW2, where German people were denied a unified nation state because of the crimes of Nazism. So for Russia it would be okay to do the same thing to Ukraine.

    Just to share some thoughts on the text, here are the things I find most problematic:

    • It refers to the idea of Ukrainian nation as "an artifice created by communists", which I find absurd an ahistorical.
    • It advocates for the collective punishment of civilians by making them endure hardships of war. A strange sentence to see but i guess it makes sense within the broader context of dismantling the Ukrainian nation state.
    • It claims Russia as the sole nation left that uphold "european values" but at the same time it claims that Russia is a leader of the decolonised world. Apart from the chauvinism, it is quite contradictory to me. Also claims that achievements of the USSR were purely of the Russian peoples. Just pains me to read stuff like this. Russia has the problem that good soviet era foreign policy has a fresh coat of chauvinist paint over it.


  • Anyway, he tells us to read the Genocide Handbook Snyder talks about and that he himself read it on the bus, he says there are explicit genocidal language used in it against Ukrainians. I don’t know what handbook he is talking about. When I looked it up just more Snyder stuff came up.

    Apparently its what Snyder calls an article published by a Russian news org. The article talks about how a denazification process would be handled in Ukraine. Its a bit dense with Russian chauvinism, but quite clear on what denazification actually entails.