Not to gatekeep, garbage people can like what I like, but I think this person is probably lying about liking the first one.

I can't quite articulate why, except that a) Oxenfree is basically a walking sim and those are generally not popular with the gamergate crowd b) the playbook of pretending you're a long-time fan of the new culture war target is really played out c) they admit to doing it before d) Netflix=woke is kind of a tell too.