Kibbutzim today are glorified gated communities. I don't know why you think they are relevant in any way.
Edit: Furthermore you'll have a tough time convincing an Arab like me to take the claim seriously that a group of Europeans who move to a british colony in the Arab world to set up their own society separate from the indigenous population is socialist, anarchist or leftist in anyway.
deleted by creator
Kibbutzim today are glorified gated communities. I don't know why you think they are relevant in any way.
Edit: Furthermore you'll have a tough time convincing an Arab like me to take the claim seriously that a group of Europeans who move to a british colony in the Arab world to set up their own society separate from the indigenous population is socialist, anarchist or leftist in anyway.