it only lasted long enough to cripple the nascent socialist movement in America
The socialist movement was crippled during the first Red Scare, long before the Depression even hit. Eugene Debs' last presidential run was in 1920, and it came from a prison cell. CPUSA's membership peaked after the New Deal.
Foregoing policies that help people right now is just accelerationism, and about the only strategy riskier than that is doing nothing at all. You can't build a movement by offering people nothing, or at least nothing until things get significantly worse.
The socialist movement was crippled during the first Red Scare, long before the Depression even hit. Eugene Debs' last presidential run was in 1920, and it came from a prison cell. CPUSA's membership peaked after the New Deal.
Foregoing policies that help people right now is just accelerationism, and about the only strategy riskier than that is doing nothing at all. You can't build a movement by offering people nothing, or at least nothing until things get significantly worse.