Greenleaf [he/him]

  • 23 Posts
  • 734 Comments
Joined 10 months ago
cake
Cake day: December 11th, 2023

help-circle
  • Well, they’re not the shittiest podcasts I guess…

    Age of Napoleon guy is at least left-adjacent, he had Christman on for a whole episode just to talk about The Eighteenth Brumaire.

    And full disclosure, I have a massive soft spot for Dan Carlin, so I may not be objective in talking about him. His podcasts were the thing that pulled me out of whatever my politics were a decade ago (he’s big into “money has corrupted the political system” thinking). He isn’t just a lib. He has a big anti-imperialist streak (he was talking about how the US shouldn’t meddle in Ukraine in 2014; and the American Peril ep is basically him saying the Spanish American War was the birth of American Imperialism) and tbh he seems like a good dude whose heart is in the right place.

    Buuuuut I had to stop listening to his history podcast years ago, because frankly it just isn’t very good. I can see why Musk likes it. He tries to be about more than just “war” but somehow war is all he ever talks about w/r/t history and is almost exclusively focused on “the west”. It’s kind of a lib cliche but Carlin really is what people who don’t actually know history think a historian sounds like. Dan pays lip service to being against Great Man Theory but his scope of history is so anti-materialist it’s hard to listen to. He connect some dots correctly but come to some really weird conclusions.

    But idk doubtful that Musk actually listens to any of this anyway.



  • I’m starting to think it’s such an obviously bad idea, is there something Israel knows that we don’t? Like, they plan on dropping a nuke on Beirut or something? Or that Biden has guaranteed 100,000 US troops and 2 carrier groups? Is there anything strategically we might be missing here?

    Back when inbred nobles decided when to go war, I can see massive blunders like this. But presumably there are professional military folks on the IOF who can understand the costs and risks and know it’s suicidal go after Hezbollah.









  • I am 1,000,000% convinced that US vets in Vietnam did in fact experience extraordinary levels of PTSD - not from hippies spitting on them or even seeing their buddies get killed (happens in every war), but from all the crimes against humanity they committed against Vietnamese civilians.


  • Gaza aid leader faces backlash over Labour Party run

    Melanie Ward, CEO of the Medical Aid for Palestinians (MAP) charity, faces major backlash from volunteers and workers after deciding to run as a Labour Party candidate in Scotland. Some 2,250 healthcare workers, medical volunteers, supporters, and donors signed a letter expressing concern.

    On June 5, a protest letter was filed by workers and volunteers at MAP, expressing their dismay to the board over Ward’s candidacy with the UK Labour Party. To run for the position of MP in Scotland’s Kirkcaldy and Cowdenbeath constituency, Ward has taken a leave of absence but has not stepped down from her position.

    Despite Ward’s pledge to make real progress for the Palestinian people if elected to Parliament, MAP is currently without an acting CEO during a healthcare collapse in Gaza. Some fear her actions could jeopardize the aid organization’s efforts on the ground, leading to threats of referring MAP to the Charity Commission.

    Ward has a history of affiliations with pro-Israel lobby groups, starting with her first trip to Palestine, organized by the Israeli Embassy-funded Union of Jewish Students (UJS). She blogged about meeting Israeli politicians and visiting settlements but shifted her perspective after a second visit to the West Bank. However, her relationship with UJS continued, including participating in a 2017 UJS panel called “Bridges Not Boycotts,” opposing boycotts of Israel.

    Ward also supported the anti-Semitism “witch hunt” during Jeremy Corbyn’s leadership, which purged much of Labour’s pro-Palestinian base, including many Jewish anti-Zionists. She tweeted, “Farewell to Jeremy Corbyn, who really was a truly terrible Labour Party Leader. He will be missed not one little bit by those of us who want to see Labour in government again.”

    In 2016, she signed a letter calling for Corbyn’s resignation, shared an article urging the public not to vote for him and tweeted the former Labour leader in 2015, “Corbyn unable to think of situation where he’d commit Forces to military action. Should think a bit harder if he wants to be PM,” in response to his anti-war stance.

    I always thought MAP was a pretty good org (and it’s possible/probable they are, just bad leadership) but no reason to give them money so long as Ward is in charge and good orgs like PCRF exist.








  • Looks like Western governments and Western media have finally gotten their ducks in a row w/r/t Biden’s “peace plan”. Olaf Scholz, the US ambassador to the UN, and others now saying “it’s on Hamas to accept this deal”. Despite the fact that Israel hasn’t agreed to shit and Hamas is politely asking that language in the agreement that obviously allows Israel to resume the genocide once they get their hostages back (which they will even more obviously taken advantage) be clarified and changed.

    It’s gaslighting right before our very eyes.



  • Fascinating. I’m curious about the current makeup of Russian exports - I assume oil is a very component?

    International currency economics is among the more complex aspects of economics IMO, so I don’t know I have any thoughts on the details. But zooming out on the situation… I can’t help but wonder if the American side has some ideological blinders on. We often say “it’s easier for some people to imagine the end of the world before the end of capitalism”. It does seem to me that westerners - including our politicians, politicians, and economists - cannot imagine a world where nations voluntarily choose to back away from neoliberalism; even if they are “losers” in the periphery. This is a huge blind spot they have and I think it plays a part in what made the first round of sanctions ineffective. I don’t doubt the West fully believes Russia will not stray from the neoliberal path.

    So it comes down to, what does Russia think? Before the SMO, I think the leadership in Russia (both political and financial) were on board with neoliberalism because they personally benefitted from it (even if the Russian people didn’t). So what have they learned in the last two years? Clearly, what they been doing has worked. They’ve had a peak behind the curtain of neoliberalism and they can now see it for what it is.

    If I had to guess, I’d say Russia decides to take a stronger position against neoliberalism and they won’t let the ruble fall. Because right now the SMO is going great for them and there isn’t a path to victory outside of a collapse of Russia’s economy. What they are doing is working so no reason to deviate. Even if you are a high up, powerful person in Russia (political or financial) and you think neoliberalism is the future for Russia… a collapse of the economy and losing the war will be very bad for your bank account, if nothing else.