What if one isn't possible? Which of the two would you choose?
Adding this because I consider it interesting, one interesting response I've been told by this person is to treat it like copyright, which she says is the view she holds. That is, something like a name or identifying code number thing or whatnot should not be shared because it's an extension of the individual and therefore would fall under copyright infringement.
People only ever replying to new things makes it seem less like a community.
Happy cake day!