Eh as long as the terminally online dweebs don't decide to split from doing some good work locally over whether or not the CIA is a trustable source then I'm Gucci with 'em
Even vocational schooling like theyre doing is an act of cultural genocide, it is just several magnitudes better than the concentration camps they US is claiming and the US is doing. But it is still an act of genocide.
Folks theyre using war on terror style justifications for what theyre doing. You can support them in their fight against US imperialism and terrorism, and you can push back against western propaganda, but for christ sake.
Good post. It's obviously not a holocaust or something and the numbers are not as high as 100 gorillion like Zenz claims but cultural genocide is still genocide. Klanada did something similar with the indigenous people by "re-educating" children in vocational schools. Nobody is denying that Canada did a cultural genocide there. I'll support China critically against imperialism and propaganda but defending their messed up shit won't get us anywhere. I understand pushing back against China in the west is bad, but I don't think we should uncritically accept whatever these schools are doing if it makes us sound like holocaust deniers.
Except now you're conflating whatever China is doing with the part of genocide of the western powers against indigenous people that involved boarding schools and whatnot, which China is also not doing. I mean I don't have a completely clear understanding of these vocational schools, but I don't think the government is trying to strip people of their identity or religion or anything. It may be some kind of assimilation potentially but I don't think it's "Kill the Indian, save the man." With this argument, you're really just trying to find another way to continue to propagandize against China.
But why defend the situation if we don't know what's happening? It's almost impossible to find the truth about what's actually happening but defending what could be cultural genocide/ assimilation isn't it. Also, the whole suspected terrorists being sent to boarding schools by the state just doesn't sit right. There are ways to push back against propaganda that don't involve defending oppressive policies.
the whole suspected terrorists being sent to boarding schools by the state just doesn’t sit right
This is just you being distrusting of foreign governments and enemies of the US. There is no reason to suspect it's anything else other than what they've stated other than some hunch based on the lies that imperialist governments tell. Your first sentence says "why defend the situation". Your second sentence then directly goes on the attack. Your third sentence digs in even more with "oppressive policies". You're telling me I shouldn't defend them, and then you're attacking without evidence again. So what's it going to be? Defend China from baseless accusations or make baseless accusations. There's never really a middle ground because not providing a counter just reinforces the dominant narrative.
I'm too tired to respond coherently but how is there no middle ground? It seems to me like you're suggesting critical skepticism of minorities being sent away to vocational schools is the same thing as the libs parroting CNN and cheering for sanctions. I want imperialists to leave China alone but I guess you're right, I can't bring myself to trust them on how they handle their anti-terrorism campaigns. We can probably agree that its a helluva lot better than bombing the shit out of people though :amerikkka:
Hell yes. Anyone defending China wrt the Uighurs should have to defend why they think it's better than what "Canada" did to their First Nations with their residential school program.
If you can defend that position, fine, but trivializing these massive oppressive state interventions won't age well. Imagine yourself 50 years down the line and Uighur victims of cultural genocide finally get a voice and describe how the lives of their people were destroyed - do you really want to be the person then who had been cheering for China?
Anyone defending China wrt the Uighurs should have to defend why they think it’s better than what “Canada” did to their First Nations with their residential school program.
For one thing, the Canadian schools forbade the First Nations people from speaking their native language and punished infractions harshly, whereas the Xinjiang schools include the native Uyghur languages in the curriculum.
The most visible sign of protection of Uyghur culture by the government is the government-run bilingual kindergarten schools where children learn Putonghua as well as Uyghur language and culture from a very young age.
A lot of anti-China propaganda is settler colonialist projection. They made similar accusations of cultural genocide against the Soviet Union, because they administrated regions with minority cultures, but they too sought to preserve native cultures in their schools.
What exactly are they doing that is cultural genocide? I have never seen a clear answer that isnt shit like wikipedia claiming that using the majority language of a multiethnic society in schooling is genocidal, which is virtually a universal policy for school systems.
Are there 16 chapos who believe in the Uyghur genocide? Really?
China not that good and etc, but really?
deleted by creator
Ah, guess the site really is growing then, which is good.
deleted by creator
I hope we have some more anarchists roaming around here. We need some diversity in opinions.
deleted by creator
Is term for "too uninformed to have decided on anarchism v. statism, but would be happy to have either"?
I've definitely decided but I know a bunch of the anarchists have fled the site since we have a communist majority.
I was talking about myself. Sorry I didn't make that clear
Ah good. Btw I really like being among all kind of leftists instead of an echo chamber.
deleted by creator
For real. This was why I liked the old r/cth. Every other leftist sub was either full AnCom or full ML and that just gets boring
Like how the rest of society is a China bad echo chamber lmaooo
deleted by creator
Eh as long as the terminally online dweebs don't decide to split from doing some good work locally over whether or not the CIA is a trustable source then I'm Gucci with 'em
deleted by creator
deleted by creator
Even vocational schooling like theyre doing is an act of cultural genocide, it is just several magnitudes better than the concentration camps they US is claiming and the US is doing. But it is still an act of genocide.
Folks theyre using war on terror style justifications for what theyre doing. You can support them in their fight against US imperialism and terrorism, and you can push back against western propaganda, but for christ sake.
Good post. It's obviously not a holocaust or something and the numbers are not as high as 100 gorillion like Zenz claims but cultural genocide is still genocide. Klanada did something similar with the indigenous people by "re-educating" children in vocational schools. Nobody is denying that Canada did a cultural genocide there. I'll support China critically against imperialism and propaganda but defending their messed up shit won't get us anywhere. I understand pushing back against China in the west is bad, but I don't think we should uncritically accept whatever these schools are doing if it makes us sound like holocaust deniers.
Except now you're conflating whatever China is doing with the part of genocide of the western powers against indigenous people that involved boarding schools and whatnot, which China is also not doing. I mean I don't have a completely clear understanding of these vocational schools, but I don't think the government is trying to strip people of their identity or religion or anything. It may be some kind of assimilation potentially but I don't think it's "Kill the Indian, save the man." With this argument, you're really just trying to find another way to continue to propagandize against China.
But why defend the situation if we don't know what's happening? It's almost impossible to find the truth about what's actually happening but defending what could be cultural genocide/ assimilation isn't it. Also, the whole suspected terrorists being sent to boarding schools by the state just doesn't sit right. There are ways to push back against propaganda that don't involve defending oppressive policies.
This is just you being distrusting of foreign governments and enemies of the US. There is no reason to suspect it's anything else other than what they've stated other than some hunch based on the lies that imperialist governments tell. Your first sentence says "why defend the situation". Your second sentence then directly goes on the attack. Your third sentence digs in even more with "oppressive policies". You're telling me I shouldn't defend them, and then you're attacking without evidence again. So what's it going to be? Defend China from baseless accusations or make baseless accusations. There's never really a middle ground because not providing a counter just reinforces the dominant narrative.
I'm too tired to respond coherently but how is there no middle ground? It seems to me like you're suggesting critical skepticism of minorities being sent away to vocational schools is the same thing as the libs parroting CNN and cheering for sanctions. I want imperialists to leave China alone but I guess you're right, I can't bring myself to trust them on how they handle their anti-terrorism campaigns. We can probably agree that its a helluva lot better than bombing the shit out of people though :amerikkka:
Well I'm glad someone likes it.
:heart-sickle:
Hell yes. Anyone defending China wrt the Uighurs should have to defend why they think it's better than what "Canada" did to their First Nations with their residential school program.
If you can defend that position, fine, but trivializing these massive oppressive state interventions won't age well. Imagine yourself 50 years down the line and Uighur victims of cultural genocide finally get a voice and describe how the lives of their people were destroyed - do you really want to be the person then who had been cheering for China?
For one thing, the Canadian schools forbade the First Nations people from speaking their native language and punished infractions harshly, whereas the Xinjiang schools include the native Uyghur languages in the curriculum.
A lot of anti-China propaganda is settler colonialist projection. They made similar accusations of cultural genocide against the Soviet Union, because they administrated regions with minority cultures, but they too sought to preserve native cultures in their schools.
What exactly are they doing that is cultural genocide? I have never seen a clear answer that isnt shit like wikipedia claiming that using the majority language of a multiethnic society in schooling is genocidal, which is virtually a universal policy for school systems.
Is "cultural genocide" something from the same realm as "cultural Marxism"? 🤔
Death to :amerikkka: will always unite us. :af-heart:
deleted by creator
What is the term we should use for things like resident schools for first nation children?
deleted by creator