It's not genocide because population is going up
is textbook Holocaust denial. Like "exhibits at Auschwitz" textbook.
the best bit is:
because they already reject a huge body of evidence that proves otherwise, they've stumbled into literally deconstructing their own Uighur genocide narrative with their own dogshit definitions
they've already forgotten that ever happened
until the next time they open a thread about China, at which point they'll forget about Israel and Palestine
the liberal brainpan can only conceptualise one completely individual idea at a time
i've seen people claim that about the uighurs. (iirc the real thing is that ethnic minorities weren't held to the one child policy.)
I think it's a weak argument with the Uighur genocide to point to increasing population, but to be fair the full argument is that the population is increasing AND there's no refugee crisis AND there's literally no evidence of genocide at all that wasn't just the made up ramblings of Adrian Zenz.
There's more Uyghurs, and they're living longer, and they're more educated, and they have better housing conditions, and they make more money, all taken together makes it very hard to make out genocide.
Yeah if the government wanted to do a genocide why would they exclude the allegedly genocided minorities from the harsh population control laws. Like they're literally making a law to decrease the population. You'd think that would be the perfect time to target it at minorities unfairly if you wanted to do genocide, but they didn't.
I think it's more about that they were excluded from the one child policy.
Oh hey, antitankie coming out as fascist, this surely never happened before! XD
how come there's so much overlap in the anti-communist and pro-fascism movements?? 🤔
Might be because fascism is direct response to communism, pure dialectics.No it's just a coincidence, in fact, communism and fascism are the same and the liberalism is the only correct option!Yeah, some people call me an ultra for no reason. I agree with them. I'm an Ultra Centrist
"The US has done more genocide and gotten away with it so it is fine"
is a hell of a take
Fuckin right. At first I was like damn these are some shit takes. Then that last line. Fuckin yiiiiiikes.
Some of you redditor liberals seriously voted to federate with these mask-off fascists.
So convenient how all these freaks ignore the in part part of the "In whole or in part" wording of the UN definition of genocide
It isn't real genocide unless it comes from Hitler's last days of fighting a losing war, otherwise it's just sparkling ethnic cleansing.
Wtf is going on with that instance? Like why haven't they scrubbed that user off their site, we've been clowning on them for like months now.
If it's been this long, and nothing's been done about that user, that community, or that community's aggregated userbase, it can be reliably assumed the people who run the instance are in on the scam. sh.itsfulla.nazis.
Why would they be scrubbed? Tankietarianism is extremely unpopular in imperial core countries, and goat's response in that screenshot seems like the bog standard take anyone under 40 who isn't a left wing extremist would have.
Crikey, wouldja lookit that, a whole flock of Amerikan Peckerwoods (Mastigia album americanus) (not to be confused with Mastigia album britannica) in their natural habitat, and in their natural routine!
Bits aside, I can't believe people actually wanted to federate with filth like that.
I'm not American. You'd know this because I type neighbour with a U in the screenshot, while Americans do not.
yeeeeeeeeeeeeah ion't believe that a second, and frankly, your input wasn't desired in the first place. I don't hold dialogues with the opps-- I just condemn them.
I'm American and you can't stop me from typing neighbour with a U in this comment
Rich coming from peoples who accuse US of genocide denial for not believing unsourced/fabricated narratives by the CIA and the literal NAZIs.
they are intentionally targeting civilian infrastructure because they want to ethnically cleanse the region. they have said this again and again and again. The fucking "well what is a genocide, really?" when government officials are talking about how Palestinians aren't human and need to be purged is such horseshit.
The second dipshit trying to say you have to kill all of them for it to be genocide is also just wrong. The UN definition states that genocide is a variety actions taken "with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group".
What Israel is doing is genocide, with no room for debate, and both these people should get the
I'm surprised I haven't seen some
connect xinjiang to people shooting down the growth rates charts on Gaza. It was used heavily by leftists as a point to cut through the Xinjiang bullshit.What they don't seem to realise is that it worked for leftists there because forced sterilisation for the cause of an ethnic Han supremacist takeover was part of the myth, not just murdering 2 million people in non-existent industrial deathcamps that also didn't show up in the numbers.
I mean for that reason specifically that argument seemed very poorly reasoned to me. Makes it way too easy for them to retreat to less absurd claims of things that are still not happening, but still genocide, like forced secularization and cultural suppression.
- The Uyghur's aren't being genocided because number go up.
